Horizons Unlimited - The HUBB

Horizons Unlimited - The HUBB (https://www.horizonsunlimited.com/hubb/)
-   Equipment Reviews (https://www.horizonsunlimited.com/hubb/equipment-reviews/)
-   -   Guglatech Filter or Mr Funnel(no joke)f1 (https://www.horizonsunlimited.com/hubb/equipment-reviews/guglatech-filter-mr-funnel-no-100112)

7800 20 Nov 2019 14:48

Guglatech Filter or Mr Funnel(no joke)f1
 
Hi Guys

I am looking at fuel tank filter. Has anyone used either the Guglatech "fuel neck prefilter"(seems very expensive for what it is) or the Mr Funnel f1(cheaper but is more messing around)

Thanks

Chris Scott 20 Nov 2019 17:05

I know a V-Stromer who used a Gulgatech (is that the Italian one?) and it caught a whole lot of crap before it got to the fuel pump in Asia.
There are other fuel socks around.
Was it that expensive - 80eu or smth?
I suppose you could MYO - the fabric looks familiar.
Mr Funnel would be a faff on a bike, IMO.

Tomkat 21 Nov 2019 11:39

I have the Guglatech neck filter on my 790 Adv. It seems like a pretty effective filter but does make filling rather slow. Firstly because the fuel has to flow through the filter under gravity. Secondly, as you fill the tank the displaced air comes out of the filler cap, but now has to flow out through the wet filter. This means as you get to the top you get a lot of frothing which slows the filling process even more. It's a hassle but for the benefit of knowing my fuel pump is protected going through the Stans I'll put up with it.

Fuel pump problems are common in that part of the world and there are plenty of stories of people burning them out, either because the upstream filter blocks so they run dry, or else because the downstream filter between the pump and injectors blocks causing the pump to run excessively high pressures. Either way avoiding dust in the pump is essential.

For this reason I've also got (but haven't yet fitted) the Guglatech filter that goes in the tank and covers the pump. Belt and braces!

7800 24 Nov 2019 08:13

Thanks guys I think that Guglatech is the way forward, less faf.

mspenz 24 Nov 2019 19:14

Filter.
 
I got a Guglatech Mazinga for my 2014 KTM690 Enduro, brilliant idea but unfortunately it won't fit, seems that the tolerance in the opening of the tank is too tight to accept the fuel pump casing with the Mazinga over the top.
The pump itself is a tight fit so I'll have to get the file out next time I have the tank opened.
A simple but sensible bit of kit.

I've also removed the in tank filter and fitted a Golan re-usable external and will be using a FloTool F1NC meantime because it's also very simple and it works!

I did try the ProFilter tank neck sock but it wasn't for me.

fefo 7 Dec 2019 17:47

hi,

I have been using them for all my trips since 2015, transafrica round around, more than 90.000 km and never an issue, I have been using all generations on my KTM 990 never suffered from fuel filter or pump issues, I would never drive any bike without, shame they haven't finished the air filter!!

Mr Funnel works around 150 microns last time I checked, Guglatech made a video comparing all filters brands and models showing how effective they are ... plenty of adventurers use them happily, nothing compares !

get them

ciao

Migolito 16 Dec 2019 20:50

Tomkat,
Can I ask you a favor? Can you do a little 30 second video of filling up? I'm looking at getting one for my Mongolia-California trip on my KTM 790AdvR and you are the only one of even heard that has one on a 790. As u know, the tank is a little bit different.
Also, I'd like to post up your vid on Advrider.com if thats ok...?

gsadvman 18 Dec 2019 22:27

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tomkat (Post 606391)
I have the Guglatech neck filter on my 790 Adv. It seems like a pretty effective filter but does make filling rather slow. Firstly because the fuel has to flow through the filter under gravity. Secondly, as you fill the tank the displaced air comes out of the filler cap, but now has to flow out through the wet filter. This means as you get to the top you get a lot of frothing which slows the filling process even more. It's a hassle but for the benefit of knowing my fuel pump is protected going through the Stans I'll put up with it.

Fuel pump problems are common in that part of the world and there are plenty of stories of people burning them out, either because the upstream filter blocks so they run dry, or else because the downstream filter between the pump and injectors blocks causing the pump to run excessively high pressures. Either way avoiding dust in the pump is essential.

For this reason I've also got (but haven't yet fitted) the Guglatech filter that goes in the tank and covers the pump. Belt and braces!

I’m riding across to Bangkok from April 2020 from U.K. and intend to fit the neck filter....do you think it necessary to fit the filter over the pump too ?

mks916 28 Dec 2019 21:50

I'm thinking about the same. Fiter for filler neck and pump.
Its recommend by Gugglatech to use both, but I'm doubt. In my opinion its sufficient to only use the filter for the fuel pump. I don't like to have difficulties while refueling due to the filler neck filter (its a KTM 790 ADV R)

mspenz 29 Dec 2019 23:47

Filter.
 
I've also tried a Profilter tank filler filter on my 690 Enduro and found it to be frustratingly slow to fill so I'm going to somehow make the pump ' Mazinga cover ' work as a fit and forget item.
Also have a look at the Golan 10 micron washable filter with the intention of fitting it between the tank and injector. Expensive but it has almost limitless use.

Golan Super Mini Filter RRP 383

Sorry, can't comment on the 790.

mks916 30 Dec 2019 21:11

is the Profilter tank filler filter also from Guglatech or a different product?

Thanks

Riel 30 Dec 2019 23:39

Different, Profill is from Australia,

Home - Profill-Australia


Guglatech is from Italy

https://www.guglatech.com/

mspenz 1 Jan 2020 19:39

Filters
 
Thanks Riel.

The guys at Guglatech have been incredibly helpful, seems that the opening to my 690 Enduro tank is slightly tight so perhaps a manufacturing anomaly, so they are making up a one off 2 layer Mazinga ( instead of the usual 3 layers ) for me to try.
If this works out I'll then sell the unused original. I can use Mr Funnel at the pump and that will remove any larger debris as well as water, the Mazinga will protect the pump itself from sucking in finer particles and the 10 micron Golan should help stop anything else getting through to the injector...I carry a spare injector anyway so most scenarios are covered !

Pickle 23 Jan 2020 01:23

I have the Guglatech filler filter on my 790R and at first I thought it was a bit slow but after chatting with the very helpful people at Guglatech I re positioned the filter inside the tank and now it actually is not bad at all.

You still need to be careful especially when its near full.

I have the pump filter also but haven't got around to installing it just yet.

You may think its a bit expensive but imagine a busted fuel pump in the middle of kazakmoliastan.... :thumbdown:

Surfy 23 Jan 2020 14:07

http://2.bp.blogspot.com/-mH91PfGQ9l...0/DSC01986.jpg

Not everytime you have a helping hand.. For tanking 250l Diesel (280L capacity), it is quite a lot of work.

We did you a MrFunnel F15C Filter. There is a link to a good storage bag (unfortunately I did`nt had it with me).

It is hard to find the Micron-Rate, but here it is labled as 74 microns.

I did just did use it in africa - in south america I did just fill up in bigger city`s. Where there a BMW X6 is refilling - there the fuel seems to be ok :rolleyes2: It was a mess to handle such an external device in any way...

Surfy

gsadvman 25 Feb 2020 16:06

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pickle (Post 608190)
I have the Guglatech filler filter on my 790R and at first I thought it was a bit slow but after chatting with the very helpful people at Guglatech I re positioned the filter inside the tank and now it actually is not bad at all.

You still need to be careful especially when its near full.

I have the pump filter also but haven't got around to installing it just yet.

You may think its a bit expensive but imagine a busted fuel pump in the middle of kazakmoliastan.... :thumbdown:

Hi...ive just got the tank filter and it seems a bit square....is there a right way to fit this as i know i have to remove tank filler and "sew"it on but is that it ?

Pips78 24 Oct 2020 21:04

Just spotted theses myself few thing that comes to mind

1.If you get the one that fits to the bike how easy is it to remove if needed looks quite a tight fit, is there a chance of it splitting then the contaminants will then get in the fuel system

2. Has anyone used the smaller universal version that does not get fitted to the bike the fuel nozzle just fits in it like a sock

https://www.guglatech.com/en/prodott...els-a00006-00/

mspenz 1 Nov 2020 18:24

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pips78 (Post 615047)
Just spotted theses myself few thing that comes to mind

1.If you get the one that fits to the bike how easy is it to remove if needed looks quite a tight fit, is there a chance of it splitting then the contaminants will then get in the fuel system

2. Has anyone used the smaller universal version that does not get fitted to the bike the fuel nozzle just fits in it like a sock

https://www.guglatech.com/en/prodott...els-a00006-00/

They are very durable, and unless you are very unlucky to fill with particularly polluted fuel they can remain in place for a long time.
I have a Mazinga over my fuel pump, a neck filler ( fixed to fit under the filler neck ) and also carry the sock version to use on my auxiliary Rade tank ( KTM690 ), I can also use it on my Tenere 1200.

Just fill more slowly :thumbup1:

Hound_Dog 10 Nov 2020 03:41

Definitely a great product and potentially saving a ton of bucks if you do a fuel pump because of crud getting in. The complaint I do have is their postage is a complete rip off. For what is basically a sock I was charged at the same price that I paid for 7kg+ of suspension parts.

Philips78 11 Nov 2020 11:38

Quote:

Originally Posted by mspenz (Post 615222)
They are very durable, and unless you are very unlucky to fill with particularly polluted fuel they can remain in place for a long time.
I have a Mazinga over my fuel pump, a neck filler ( fixed to fit under the filler neck ) and also carry the sock version to use on my auxiliary Rade tank ( KTM690 ), I can also use it on my Tenere 1200.

Just fill more slowly :thumbup1:


I have seen the sock one that's the universal filter I think???

mspenz 12 Nov 2020 20:55

Quote:

Originally Posted by Philips78 (Post 615524)
I have seen the sock one that's the universal filter I think???

Yes, they're made of slightly thicker material so that they can be used every time you fill instead of having one ( or two ) fixed in place on the filler and pump.

Tomkat 15 Nov 2021 10:12

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tomkat (Post 606391)
I've also got (but haven't yet fitted) the Guglatech filter that goes in the tank and covers the pump. Belt and braces!

Update: I've now had the time to try and fit the "Mazinga" pump cover filter and have some experience to share.

First, as another contributor commented, it doesn't fit. When you add the thickness of the filter to the pump it is too large to go through the (quite close tolerance) hole in the tank. You get so far and the filter just jams and concertinas up, and there is no way it will go any further. Both a KTM dealer and myself have tried this now and we came to the same conclusion. I suppose it would be possible to dremel or scrape out the hole in the tank, but I didn't want to do this - the surface of the tank needs to be perfectly flat an undamaged for the pump to seat on, so any damage or excessive enlargement of the hole and fuel will leak past the seal. With replacement tanks costing over £1,000 this was not something I'm willing to risk.

Second, having looked closely at the pump I believe this filter gives no benefit, in fact it could make the blockage risk worse. Despite being a large surface area of excellent filtration material there is no point in covering the entire pump. The fuel inlet is a small hole about 4mm diameter right at the base of the pump sidewall, so the only part of the filter that is doing anything is the small section of gauze covering that hole. If there is dirt in the tank that part of the filter will block long before the inbuilt filter in the pump, starving it and causing all the burnout problems we want to avoid.

In summary, the tank neck filter works, albeit with disadvantages, but the pump sock filter is a waste of money.

This is just my experience, if anyone would like a 790/890 pump sock filter ("Mazinga") it's yours for £30 (half price), never fitted or used ;)


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 08:03.


vB.Sponsors