Horizons Unlimited - The HUBB

Horizons Unlimited - The HUBB (https://www.horizonsunlimited.com/hubb/)
-   North Africa (https://www.horizonsunlimited.com/hubb/north-africa/)
-   -   Egypt - new airfield from WWII (https://www.horizonsunlimited.com/hubb/north-africa/egypt-new-airfield-from-wwii-60236)

ursula 15 Nov 2011 09:46

Egypt - airfields from WWII
 
hello all

I found an old airfield from WWII in the Western Desert. It is built the same way as "8 Bells" in the south of Gilf Kebir. with a lot of Shell jerrycans.

The name is either 0 HILL oder C HILL or Q HILL or ......

Does anybody know more about this landing ground?

byebye
Ursula

ursula 15 Nov 2011 09:51

a view is on my page on Flickr

Airfield in the Western Desert | Flickr - Photo Sharing!

3M 15 Nov 2011 12:10

Brilliant
 
hello Ursula
congratulations for the new find !
I honestly think you are a daring desert explorer,
will contact Tarek soon but im curious about the western borders will be important to know:
Any encounters or spotting smugglers or illegal migrations?
Best regards from Egypt
Mahmoud

ursula 15 Nov 2011 12:22

smugglers in the western desert
 
hi Mahmoud

nice to hear from you!
So you did not know this airport too? there were no car tracks at all - untill we came :cool4:

Yes, we had one of these encounters...
at the east end of Wadi Assib we met 2 "libyans" hidden in the small barchanes and Tarek was speeding off like in a rallye...

all the best
Ursula

3M 15 Nov 2011 12:39

maybe hunters
 
no I did not know about it, you know 8b is quite famous and I guess the new one was not known despite all the efforts to trace back this area history
Also for the Libyans, one possibility that this is the season for falconry, birds of Europe they escape the cold weather and immigrate to Africa around September, they are hunted by poor Bedouins then sold to rich Bedouins to play with! The hunters area used to be in the great sand sea close to clayton camp , maybe they are on the hunt for birds ! or that’s what I hope
Best regards
Mahmoud

andrasz 15 Nov 2011 14:20

Hello Ursula,

Well done! On my 1943 US Army Map Service Libyan Desert sheet there are two airfields marked, Cleft-Hill and Garth-Hill, your find must be one of the two. Send me an email, from the position I will be able to tell which one.

From your photos I see that the Tourist Police have excelled themselves...

Edit: No need to email, have found it on Google Earth, stands out quite clearly if you know where to look :)
It is indeed Garth-Hill aerodrome, one of the many emergency landing grounds on the air route leading to Kufra (8 Bells was one of them). Seems to be quite a bit off the regular route to the Gilf...

ursula 15 Nov 2011 16:26

Garth Hill
 
thanks - in the meantime I found it on the 1942 US Army Map too but no infos in the net at all.


yes, Tourist Police was really very exceptionnel this time :thumbdown:
have you seen the accident and their machine guns?
just what one is looking for in the desert...

http://www.flickr.com/photos/7266438...in/photostream

andrasz 15 Nov 2011 16:56

Out of curiosity, how much time was wasted getting their car upright... ?

Regarding Garth Hill landing ground, I would be surprised if this name and the fact that the residence of Hubert Penderel (RAF officer, travel companion of Almasy and Bagnold) was in Garth, Pontardawe, Wales was pure coincidence...

ursula 17 Nov 2011 10:49

wasted time....
 
no problem - our crew was very experienced!

- we lost much more time waiting for the officer and the Tourist Police Escort in
Bahariya and Dakhla,

- for a spare part for TP car no1 with new drivers/mecanos to
bring it to us into the Great Sandsea!

- and waiting for car no2 after the accident, car no1 was driven back to Bahariya

on the 6th day we arrived finally in the north of Gilf Kebir...

bye
Ursula

ursula 16 Jun 2012 11:00

Garth Hill Western Desert Egypt
 
hi
in April I made another picture of the name of this landing ground
in the Western Desert

it is clearly readable " G HILL "
http://up.picr.de/10850407uu.jpg

Ursula

Tonyb42uk 31 Dec 2013 11:51

Andrasz,
Could I ask whether the US Army maps quote the Landing Ground No. (for example, LG.248) or a map reference for Garth Hill. I am trying to establish it's location with regard to some pre war RAF records.
Thank you, Tony

Toyark 31 Dec 2013 13:48

Ursula
Question- sorry to jump in here
This is the oldest representation of a Figure-four dead fall rap I have seen.
Have you any indication of the age of the markings?

andrasz 31 Dec 2013 13:56

Tony,

All the Landing Grounds are marked with blue crosses, and in SW Egypt all are named - e.g. Garth Hill, which clearly refers to the landing ground itself, not any topographical feature. The arrangement of the landing grounds clearly indicate that they were marked out in late 1932, when Penderel flew a number of reconnaissance missions across the Glf and down to Uweinat/Kissu (to support the Bagnold expedition).

In S.E. Libya some of the landing grounds are marked LG.nn, corresponding to the old Italian "Campo di Fortuna" numberings, going from 1-10 along the Gialo-Kufra-Uweinat route, while some others (e.g. "Kendall's", "Lazarus") clearly correspond to LRDG activities.

andrasz 31 Dec 2013 14:06

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bertrand (Post 448597)
This is the oldest representation of a Figure-four dead fall rap I have seen.

Sorry, but that is a giraffe, even if a rather crude and partially eroded one. Can be anything from mid-Holocene to early historic, but the engravings in the Dakhla vicinity (as this one) are generally considered to be from late prehistory (4000-2000B.C.)

ursula 31 Dec 2013 15:06

engraving of a Giraffe
 
hi Bertrand - hi Andras
this Giraffe "lives" in the northern part of Gilf Kebir not near Dakhla.
I wonder if you can see also some kind of saddle on its back?
Ursula

PS what is a "Figure-four dead fall rap" ???

Toyark 31 Dec 2013 15:12

oops lost a 't'
It's a figure of 4 Trap- sorry can't type!
Dead fall- a stone is held up by one or more sticks- animal dislodges stick/s and gets whacked on the head etc by the stone usually meeting its maker!
Also known as the Paiute Trap
No artifacts? darn!

andrasz 1 Jan 2014 20:01

Hi Ursula,

I mixed it up with a very similar one near DWM.

I think what you see on the back is some other unrelated animal figure, either over or under, but it is not very clear.

Threewheelbonnie 2 Jan 2014 19:04

What a fascinating thread. Thank you for posting.

Andy

andrasz 4 Jan 2014 11:02

Sadly this is like most of the threads we used to have here, before the spring :stormy:...

ursula 5 Oct 2014 11:00

Egypt - Cleft Hill Airstrip Western Desert
 
Tarek showed us another landing ground in the Western Desert not far from Garth Hill

Cleft Hill on Google
http://up.picr.de/19719641tz.jpg

I was very surprised about the number of large single tracks, asking myself from
what kind of vehicle they could be.
Any idea?


Ursula

ursula 5 Oct 2014 11:03

Airport Cleft Hill Western Desert
 
to compare our small Toyota tracks from left to right
http://up.picr.de/19710240qp.jpg

single large tracks
http://up.picr.de/19710241gt.jpg

Whiskey 7 Oct 2014 09:22

Ursula, just guess. Maybe caravan tracks?

Thomas

ursula 8 Oct 2014 09:37

Cleft Hill Garth Hill airport Western Desert
 
Hi Thomas –
thats exactly what I was thinking too before I saw the straight dynamic
semicircular tracks on Google http://up.picr.de/19719641tz.jpg

usually camel tracks look more zigzaged – snaked - meandrered like
http://up.picr.de/19745494gp.jpg
http://up.picr.de/19745495jm.jpg
http://up.picr.de/19745496ss.jpg

or maybe from some speedy drunken camels full of aviation benzine beer ???

andrasz 8 Oct 2014 15:18

Really bizarre, no idea.

We already had a lengthy discussion with Tarek on another forum re camel tracks, petrol and supplies for these emergency fields were flown in, there is zero evidence to suggest that camels would have been used for any logistics support.

Richard Washington 9 Oct 2014 13:48

Could the single tracks be the nose or tail wheel of an aircraft? In a tight turn that single wheel might dig in more than the others.

andrasz 9 Oct 2014 14:03

Definitely not tailwheel (all aircraft in use at the time were tail-draggers), track much too wide. The only thing I can possibly think of is perhaps a shallow ditch excavated by prop-wash once the aircraft were taxiing, but the edges appear too abrupt for that, and there are stones on the ground which are much too heavy to de dislodged by prop-wash.

Richard Washington 11 Oct 2014 13:37

Quote:

Originally Posted by andrasz (Post 482211)
Definitely not tailwheel (all aircraft in use at the time were tail-draggers), track much too wide.

A complication with identifying old tracks is that their form will change over decades. Once a track is introduced it changes the near-surface friction velocity by altering the roughness and that, in turn, changes the turbulence profile and deflation capability near the tracks. As a result the same background wind can become more erosive in the vicinity of the newly introduced track compared with the surronds and, as a result, fine sediment is more easily transported from the track and track edges. Track form therefore changes - possibly widening, possibly also creating deposition downwind of the tracks in the same way that nebkha dunes form near small vegetation features. Simply put, I doubt the tracks originally looked like they do now.

andrasz 12 Oct 2014 15:16

Agreed, but on the photos larger stones are clearly pushed aside forming a low rim along the track edges (2nd photo, track at upper right). Cannot see any way wind can do that.

Also for aircraft of the times, most weight was on main wheels not on tail wheel, so plane tracks should be double or triple (tail wheel would have been just a few inches wide). The stones piled to the side argue against the prop-wash theory too.

:confused:

ursula 29 Jul 2019 12:48

Cleft Hill LRDG airstrip Egypt Western Desert
 
Looking at my old pics…

https://up.picr.de/36369138ja.jpg

Jay_Benson 29 Jul 2019 21:42

Did anyone come up with a logical explanation of the origin of the elliptical tracks?

ursula 2 Aug 2019 16:07

Cleft Hill LRDG airstrip Egypt Western Desert
 
could this picture help ?

https://up.picr.de/36419196hc.jpg

or the sat map ?

https://up.picr.de/36419238hk.jpg

the tracks are really mysterious !

https://up.picr.de/36420129xk.jpg

https://up.picr.de/36456788ud.jpg

ursula 6 Sep 2019 15:48

Egypt - airfields from WWII
 
Maybe you like my album "Airfields, Wrecks and Jerrycans"

https://www.flickr.com/photos/182588...57710065267072

Herr_Bünzli 25 Sep 2019 14:53

Quote:

Originally Posted by ursula (Post 602913)
the tracks are really mysterious !

Has anyone ever crossposted this thread to an aviation forum or the like? I mean no disrespect, but I think guesswork in this forum won't lead anywhere.

andrasz 1 Oct 2019 07:00

@Herr_Bünzli
I know there are many WWII aviation historians lurking on this forum, they are as baffled as anyone else. The tracks are unlike anything one would expect to have been made by aircraft of the day, see discussion above.

tony johnston 4 Oct 2019 16:01

I have seen high flotation,wide wheelbase,geophysical survey vehicles operating in Abu dhabi and Oman.Could it be this or,similar.They usually travel in a series of parallel straight lines so these should also be able to be seen.The circles may be corraling at the end of the day!

andrasz 9 Oct 2019 08:25

The source of the mystery is that the tracks are quite clearly single, unlike anything one would expect from multi-wheeled craft.

Flyingkiwi2020 10 Oct 2019 03:08

Interesting thread guys.
Any updates?
Or will it all be lost to history?

andrasz 17 Oct 2019 13:02

There are two images among the Arkwright photographs that might give a clue. They show a Thornycroft lorry dragging something on a long rope in the sand. There is no caption to provide any explanation for the purpose of the exercise, but that would leave a track very similar to the ones being contemplated:


https://fjexpeditions.com/desert/his...ht/FGBA_45.jpg


https://fjexpeditions.com/desert/his...ht/FGBA_44.jpg

Chris Scott 28 Jan 2020 22:48

Flying over Zerzura
 
2 Attachment(s)
A plug for mate of mine. I hope no one minds.

Flying over Zerzura

https://www.amazon.it/Flying-Zerzura.../dp/8888180257

andrasz 25 Mar 2020 15:03

Mystery solved !
 
Watching the original footage of the Bagnold expeditions on youtube it became clear that these marks were left by the old tail-dragger Vickers Victorias of RAF 216 sqn. Unlike later aircraft with a tail wheel, they only had a tail skid which made a deep trough in the soft terrain, but the wheels with the rubber tires did not sink in. This explains the single tracks. The still from the video illustrates it nicely:


https://www.fjexpeditions.com/expedi...s_victoria.jpg

Richard Washington 25 Mar 2020 16:25

Quote:

Originally Posted by Richard Washington (Post 482207)
Could the single tracks be the nose or tail wheel of an aircraft? In a tight turn that single wheel might dig in more than the others.

Close but no cigar....

andrasz 26 Mar 2020 09:39

Quote:

Originally Posted by Richard Washington (Post 610403)
Close but no cigar....

Certainly worth an honourable mention... :)

andrasz 26 Mar 2020 09:46

Now that we know what made them, it is actually possible to see the tracks made by the main wheels on either side of the deeper tail skid mark on this photo of Ursula:

Quote:

Originally Posted by ursula (Post 602913)
could this picture help ?

https://up.picr.de/36419196hc.jpg


Richard Washington 26 Mar 2020 13:21

I keep having to remind myself how long those single tracks have been there. Seven decades or so and counting - with plenty of wind energy to move sediment around multiple times a month. Think of all the tracks we've driven out in the Sahara and Libyan desert over the years.

andrasz 26 Mar 2020 17:37

These are the tracks of Prince Kemal el Din's Citroens from 1926 at Uweinat (taken in 2015):


https://fjexpeditions.com/expedition...ov17/P2970.jpg


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 03:33.


vB.Sponsors