Greetings Paperfoot
We also looked for a mesh/regular jacket for both the hot and cold parts of our trip (Alaska to Panama/Argentina) as it turned out quite a lot of the trip was colder than we expected but having the mesh for the journey south of Mexico City was a bonus.
The jackets we had were Joe Rocket Alter Ego 2.0 I would rate them a 7.5/10
The down side of these jackets were
- A bit short in the body (from your description I think I am the same height/build as you)
- removing the outer textile layer to expose the mesh inner was fiddly (road grime made the zips very stiff to undo)
- The waterproof layer was a separate removable layer on the inside of the jacket (We used a separate outer rain jacket and pants to keep the rain off and also as first layer against the cold)
- while it was windproof it wasn't as heavy duty as other jackets but we wanted something for the hotter climates (For the colder parts of the trip I used a Widder heated vest and that was fantastic, keeping your body core warm and wearing a long sleeved merino top, etc made up for the lighter weight jacket)
That was in 2007, there is now a version 3.0 of this jacket that I've just bought
JoeRocket.com
I haven't tried it yet but it looks like they have made several improvements
- they now come in tall sizes with longer arm lengths (but only in black, I bought a large tall)
- instead of unzipping the textile panel to expose the mesh, the entire textile jacket is removed in one piece (no zips). As before the armour is attached to inner mesh jacket so you still have the protection (The downside is you have a complete jacket to strap on the bike)
- The outer textile layer is also the waterproof layer. I don't know how waterproof it is but I will still take my rain jacket and pants anyway as a first layer of weather protection.
- it feels like a heavier jacket but I'm still taking the heated vest with me
I'll come back with a road report when I get some wet weather
We also had the Alter Ego pants but I never bothered removing the panels to expose the mesh. I have no complaints about them and will take them again.
We started the trip with some Kevlar jeans but I felt my knees were a bit exposed and wanted some padding around them, also as someone else mentioned denim takes ages to dry
I think our clothing choice worked well for us but as we were two up on a big bike we didn't plan to do any hard core off road (or at least a minimal amount) and your type of riding may affect your choice.
Good Luck
Ian J