Hello,
I'm preparing for a trip to Alaska and I've got two of the Kolpin 1.5 gal Jr fuel canisters and need some help in deciding how to mount the canisters to my DR650.
The issues I'm dealing with:
- center of gravity of the bike with fuel canisters mounted and filled
- crash outcome (what would happen in different crash scenarios with the fuel, plastic containers being damaged and leaking)
- rider comfort (fuel canisters causing discomfort)
I'm always planning for the worst-case scenario and this being fuel is more of a concern. I'm also planning for the long haul. Planning to do Central and South America next year and hopefully Africa and RTW at some point. So, everything I'm doing to the bike, it's with all this in mind.
The easiest solution seems to be mounting them to the rear of the panniers, but that would add so much weight hanging off the rear and I think the frame (bike and luggage rack) would be over-stressed.
I didn't think about mounting them to the front of the panniers until I saw this picture of Herbert on his Africa trip and I've taken pictures below of how that would look on my bike.
Quote:
This is pretty much what Herbert and Ramona used on their Africa trip.
|
I'm most in favor of mounting them under the panniers as they're out of sight and out of the way. Crashing (low-siding on dry asphalt) with under pannier mounted canisters seems to be the biggest issue. I've contacted a few riders who have the canisters mounted on the bottom and they say handling is greatly improved and they've just acknowledged the fact that if they crash on dry asphalt, it could get ugly (one of them crashed on wet asphalt and had no issues and the other crashed on a dirt track with no issues too).
But this 1.5 Gal Kolpin tank seems a bit big for the pannier (canister is 12"x12" and pannier is 9" wide) and if it's mounted at the front or the rear, seems like it would be the first part of the bike to touch during a drop and slide causing it to be a problem regardless of how it's mounted.
Right now this is my ranking of how I'd like them mounted:
1 - under pannier
2 - in front of pannier
3 - rear of pannier
4 - mounted on rear of top box
Mounting them on the top box (still to arrive) looks like the safest option regarding the canisters being damaged in a crash, but that would add so much extra weight to the top box, which I'm trying to keep as light as possible as I've read and heard that top racks have failed quite often out on the road being overloaded.

Canister in front of pannier

Canister on bottom of pannier

Rear view of bottom mounted and Zoey
Regarding how much clearance I have - it's not that bad. I was touching the canisters while I was rolling the bike back but it didn't hinder too much. It did block easy access to the kick stand on the other side, but it's still possible to bring the stand down.
So what do you guys think? If the canister is mounted on the side panniers (in any orientation), it's going to be the first thing to touch the ground during a drop and possibly be compromised and leak. So, I think I'm going for the under pannier mount.
Also, I'm thinking that I'll only probably put fuel in the canisters when I'm taking on some deserted stretches of road (Prudhoe Bay, Tierra del Fuego, etc), and those kind of roads would probably not be paved so crashing on them with fuel mounted on the bottom might not be an issue...