Ok Gents and Lass's,


I am a complete Mapoholic and consequently know Jack S*** about nav gear. I'm planning on a big trip in hopefully 2 years time so at the cost that they are I don't want to buy something that is flawed out in the field so to speak. I'm fancying the TCAT east to west to kick start the adventure then a west coast top to very bottom focussing on SA. I could spend the rest of this year researching through HU picking up threads relating to this topic but could you chip in here with broard advise and tips etc please..??
I am also fancying a hand held device for some unknown reason too, good or bad..???


Thanks in advance
MEZ

If you like maps why not use one?

If you want to try one I'd buy a simple Etrex style hand held walkers unit off E-bay and some ear buds that fit your phone. Get out over the summer and see if you are going to prefer the turn by turn your phone will do near home or the simple point at the target the bobblehatters one will do. Once you know if you'll use it to replace the maps, save you if you get washed out to sea, find hotels in city centres or run your whole trip including calculating the fuel use and finding coffee shops you'll know what type you want.

Once you know how you use it you will know more about wanting to store way points or download fully detailed maps.

Andy

Thanks for replying Andy, I will take on board your thoughts for sure...


I have basically decided to drag my sorry un-navigated arse into this century and purchase one later this year for sure so all info and opinions appreciated...


Mez

I'm a phone convert. I basically bimble about the place in a semi-lost state until cold/hungry/dark at which point I typically want somewhere with a decent eating/drinking establishment. I don't need some silicone valley tart telling me "Off rowt, make a Yooo-Tuurn" all day, but heading for the hotel it is nice to have my phone (which I carry anyway and plays music and holds books and talks to me like Fenella Fielding) help with complex junctions.


I used to use dedicated units (GPS V, then GPS CSx, then TomTom Rider2) which are a) more accurate away from a phone signal and b) can take you along routes all day every day so you stick to the plan. These vary in price, size and power use to a massive extent. The ones where you just enter a post code (TomTom etc. as bought from Halfords or Argos) don't understand that sheep tracks are nicer than Motorway, the blank page type (Garmins and the like as sold by Touratech and so forth) need detailed programming if you want to use all they can do. This is easy at home on a PC, nigh on impossible using the built on buttons. The walkers type (Etrex etc.) is just like having an idiot proof compass that points at the target.


Andy

In just a couple of posts, Andy has pretty well summarised it for me regarding the electronic gizmos.

As for the Etrex range it is just that - a range.
Garmin are very cute at bringing out a new model of nearly all their products at regular intervals (they are far from unique in this; the whole computer-based business has followed the same marketing model for many years).
The net result is that there are quite a few models of Etrex so you would have to start down the road of doing your own research, sooner or later; after a while that gets tedious, which is but one reason why I stick with my really old Nuvi Garmin combined with smart phones/tablets (running the free apps) "as and when".

And, I have never managed to give up reading maps; they are so much more intellectual. ;-)

__________________
Dave

multi tiered line of defence on our current RTW trip. iphone apps. google maps and Garmin Nuvi. dont assume you will find maps in many countries. you work it out on the road. oh and of course just stop and ask the locals.

If you have an android smart phone with gps look at osmand

Buy a good satnav.. and here's the secret... learn to use it properly.

If you can get decent maps of where you want to go and are happy using them then stick with those. You don't have to chuck them in the bin just because electronics have come along.

I started by just using the lat /lon feature on my mid 90's Garmin (that's just about all it would do) as a means of working out where I was when my map reading went wrong. I'd get a lat/lon reading from the Garmin and just look it up on the map to work out where I was (you have to use maps that have lat /lon along the edge - so nothing from McDonalds ). I used that system for years until I got TomTom software running on an old PDA and started using that instead.

The main problem with TomTom style sat-nav is that with maps you made all the decisions yourself by looking at a map where you understood what the colours and the lines meant. Sat-nav is like having a very attentive but essentially idiot person map reading on the back and giving you directions. Without setting the ground rules they'll give equal weighting to a cart track and a motorway and tell you to take the second exit at a roundabout when the first exit is a footpath that you discount.

If you've got a smartphone there's loads of free satnav software available. I currently use NavFree on both my iPhone (on the bike) and iPad (in the Land Rover). It was free with UK maps and extra Euro country maps are about £2 each. It's slightly more awkward to use than TomTom but for free .... It just uses the satellite signals so it'll work anywhere - it doesn't need a phone signal (my iPad doesn't even have a sim card in it). Try something like that for a while until you get the hang of it and if you decide it's crap just bin it. Just be aware that in the same way that calculators mean that no-one can do mental maths any more, if you let the (tin) brain take the strain you'll forget how to read a map after a while.

Kind of begs the question really.
Broad enough though

__________________
Dave

Hi again!

Im going to nab you for some more info if i can! Im considering using an ipad for a sat nav for my May trip (another thread where you've kindly offered your thoughts). I was considering downloading the TomTom maps for Europe. Stupid question, that ipad you're using is the wifi/3G model right and not just the wifi version, i know it might be a dumb question but I just like hearing it exactly how it is!!? Im thinking of slipping the ipad into the top of the tank bag and using it like that.

I need a reliable sat nat that if i see a cool road and decide to go off the planned route that it will recalculate properly and get me going again rather than backtracking.

Cheers in advance!

Colm.

Hi Colm

My iPad is an iPad mini. It is a wifi +3G version but as it doesn't have a sim card in it it's working as wifi only. As I mentioned before I'm running it with free sat-nav software and it works very well.

Being wifi only the sat-nav is running from the internal maps that you download before you leave so there's no way it can go online via the 3G phone network and run up second mortgage bills. That's the way I want it to be. The iPhone does have a sim card and while I use it on the bike(s) I tend to stick with an old pda that runs TomTom sat nav. TomTom software is def easier to use although I've run both of them side by side in the Land Rover and they pick pretty much the same routes.

I'd certainly put the iPad mini into the tank bag map compartment and use it because it would fit in inside its case but we also have a full size one and that won't go in at all (I've just tried). Even if your tank bag is bigger than mine I'd be a bit worried about using it - they're a little fragile for that (our one is only used around the house and it's on its third screen (and that's cracked)).

I've chucked the pda into the tank bag map compartment and used it all over Europe both summer and winter without any problems. In your position I'd be seriously considering buying a cheap car Tom Tom sat-nav on eBay, using that in the tank bag and keeping the iPad for route planning in the evenings.

I tend to use sat nav to take the strain out of reading signposts and deciding which way to go at T junctions. I'd never get off the ferry in Calais and just set it to Athens (or wherever I was going) because it would probably route me through Moscow or Stockholm or somewhere stupid. Instead I decide for myself which route I want to take and make a list of intermediate points probably no more than 50 miles apart. That way it's likely to chose sensible roads.

With TomTom choosing the "shortest route" option is the way to be routed along dirt tracks and through front gardens. Go with "fastest route" to avoid that. Even then there are times when it makes crazy decisions - like 2 miles down a dirt road to do a U turn and detouring me 5 miles through a village and bringing me out onto the main road 200m from where I started (both of those in northern France). Other than that it does make nav a lot easier. No more stopping at crossroads and spending 20mins with a map trying to work out whether to turn left or right. I've not bothered with bluetooth in-ear directions and tend to turn the sound off. The pics are good enough.

Mez:

Rather than trying to answer your question in great detail, let me give you some general conceptual guidance instead.

When making long voyages through areas you are not familiar with, there are two possible ways to approach the issue of route planning, navigation, and moment-to moment orientation to your present position:

1) You work primarily from maps, and use an electronic device as an 'assistant' (in other words, to help you pinpoint your present position on the map), or;

2) You program the electronic device with your route, and use it as your primary guidance device, reserving the paper maps primarily for planning purposes (i.e. for reference when programming the electronic device the night before, or when a major detour is needed from the route you have programmed into your electronic device).

My own experience has taught me that if my main objective is to 'transit' a route (meaning, just get from A to B in the most efficient manner), pre-programming the electronic device and then using it as my primary navigation guidance is the simplest and most efficient way of doing things.

On the other hand, if I want to 'tour' an area (explore it, look around, get a feel for the place), it's better to work off of a paper map on the tank bag, and only to use the electronic device to occasionally confirm your position (meaning, assure yourself that you actually are where you think you are).

If you are planning to make a LONG trip, such as a cross-continent trip, chances are that your style of travel will alternate between 'transit' and 'touring' as you go along. Hence, choose your navigation methodology according to what your daily objective is.

I do recommend that when you purchase an electronic navigation device, you ensure it meets the following criteria:

1) Waterproof.

2) Big enough display that you can easily interpret it when driving or riding.

3) Has auto-routing and auto-recalculation capability.

4) Does not depend on cell phone reception.

You stated that you plan to make your trip in 2 years' time. That being the case, I suggest you not buy your electronic navigation device until no earlier than 6 months before departing on your trip. The technology (not to mention the cartography within the device) is improving every year, the price is also going down every year.

Michael

[QUOTE=backofbeyond;501144]
My iPad is an iPad mini. It is a wifi +3G version but as it doesn't have a sim card in it it's working as wifi only. As I mentioned before I'm running it with free sat-nav software and it works very well.
[QUOTE]

Ditto for my Nexus 7 (as per the name it has a 7 inch screen) expect that it runs the Android operating system of course.
Mine does not have a 3/4G capability so it has no SIM card (deliberately purchased without that capability - therefore the phone companies can't possibly snope on what I am doing and where I am ;-)

__________________
Dave

While you wait for that 6 months before you leave (great advice IMO), download some free apps to your phone (assuming you're not on a Nokia 3610) OSM, Orux, .... And play with those... Especially Orux supports a wide range of maps, so it is likely to end up on a waterproof tablet of yours or a large waterproof cellphone like a Sony Xperia z3. And the OSM maps can also be run on Garmin devices (I haven't tried but some geek who knows stuff said it works on a forum). Apps are free and like that you can compare...