Life after the Africa Twin

[uk_vette]

Hi all,

I had the use of a late (2000) AT for a year, and finally gave it back to my brother end of last summer (2011)

Now during that time, I would regularly go for ride outs, and one of my good friends was on a BMW F 800 GS. I think it was a 2009.

The same vein of adventure bike that the AT was.

However, it always felt the BMW was so much more advanced than the AT, as good as the AT was, it never had any where near the power the BMW had.

So where to next, I have never really liked the BMW's but maybe times are changing?

Has any one had direct comparison between the AT and the 650cc BMW or the 800cc BMW and the 750cc AT.
I get confused with the newer BMW F650 which is actually an 800cc, (why did they do that )
Please post your opinions, findings, call them what you may.

I know the smaller engine BMW is a single cyl, which many have said is a vibratory monster, and to opt for the twin.

Most, if not all my riding is on tarmac, with possible some hard compact gravel roads.

vette

[barothi]

If you ride mostly on tarmac, get a road bike. Buying a large enduro bike for tarmac doesn't make sense at all. You will get far better cornernig, top speed, comfort and even fuel consumption with a road bike. I rode on pretty bad roads, sand and rocky trails with my Suzuki GS 500.

Just my opinion, get a Kawasaki W800 or Triumph Bonnie, or maybe a Triumph Scrambler. Sure, you won't look like Ewan or Charlie but they will be way more stylish and practical on tarmac.

[Vaufi]

Originally Posted by uk_vette

Hi all,
.....

I get confused with the newer BMW F650 which is actually an 800cc, (why did they do that )
Please post your opinions, findings, call them what you may.

I know the smaller engine BMW is a single cyl, which many have said is a vibratory monster, and to opt for the twin.

Most, if not all my riding is on tarmac, with possible some hard compact gravel roads.

vette

What about the Triumph 800 ? Seems to be a great bike, but not cheaper than the Beemer 800GS. I suppose nobody knows why the F650 is named this way. The F-series all have the 800cc parallel twin. Probably the F650 has the frame of the old 650 enduro, but comes with the 800cc engine. To make things even more confusing the old F650 thumper is now called G650.
Personally I'd prefer the enduro type bike to any road bike. The enduro is IMHO much more comfortable for travelling. No need to fit knobblies if you're only riding tarmac.

[uk_vette]

Hi all,

I have had the road bikes in the past, and some really fancy point and squirt stuff. > 260km/h
I am happier on an Enduro / adventure type bike hense the AT and the BMW.

One bike that has crossed my mind more than once is teh Yamaha TDM.
My friend had the early TNM 850, an I was quite impressed with it.
Now of course thay have moved up to 900cc and I think there is a gearbox change also?

So how is the TDM fitting into my picture, 850 or 900 like I said, mostly tarmac.

vette

[Walkabout]

Originally Posted by uk_vette

Hi all,

I have had the road bikes in the past, and some really fancy point and squirt stuff. > 260km/h
I am happier on an Enduro / adventure type bike hense the AT and the BMW.

One bike that has crossed my mind more than once is teh Yamaha TDM.
My friend had the early TNM 850, an I was quite impressed with it.
Now of course thay have moved up to 900cc and I think there is a gearbox change also?

So how is the TDM fitting into my picture, 850 or 900 like I said, mostly tarmac.

vette

I've never owned a TDM but I have been on a friends' 850, quite a few years ago, and I do think that this bike remains very under estimated. It has not been a big seller in the UK but, again, it has a following and they come up at very attractive second hand prices quite regularly.
It is still in production and I saw a new one just yesterday in a dealer with an asking price of £6600. Of course, all Yamaha new bikes are very expensive at present in the UK - this has been ascribed to the Yen-£ exchange rate but I am not so sure; certainly the dealers are prepared to do deals! £1000 off for a new XT660Z Tenere for instance.

The list price for a Vmax is £21,500 by the way; just thought you would like to know that.

[Zimi]

In Switzerland you can have TDM 850 for dirt cheap, around 1500-2000$, nobody wants them. And I can tell you why. I have one and did around 40'000km with it. The bike I disliked the most to any other bike I rod, but then I was not very experimented and thought it looked good.

First it's very heavy, the center of gravity is very high, and in comparaison with a good old BMW R100GS, it seems much heavier. Then, then engine. it's personnal but I prefear to have an engine that vibrates, that some some noise, rather than something that seems to be an electric engine, with no noise at all... Absolutely not exiting. After that I got myself a Dominator, and was much happier riding, even with almost half of the power.

Then. As soon as you need to do something on this, bike, oyu have to take of all the fairings and the tank, even to access the battery.

[THEHAPPYWANDERER]

Hi there I had a 91 AT and loved the look the ride basically everything except the weight and the height I am 5'7 with a 28" inside leg so when I swapped for a single cylinder 650cc BMW funduro (97)I was amazed at the difference in height and weight. FWIW I think the single cylinder thumper is fantastic its got plenty of torque and cruises comfortably at 80 contrary to what everyone else says I have no problem with vibrations and regularly travel on the motorways. Nearly all my riding is on tarmac with a little gravel and dirt tracks and the funduro copes, no not copes thrives on both surfaces. I personally do not like the new F650 (800cc) probably because I havent actually ridden one but they arent singles so as long as mine keeps doing all I ask of it I wont be changing lol Try an old funduro with easily 65 MPG and soooo comfortable.
Keep Upright Bill

[Walkabout]

Originally Posted by uk_vette

Hi all,

I had the use of a late (2000) AT for a year, and finally gave it back to my brother end of last summer (2011)

Now during that time, I would regularly go for ride outs, and one of my good friends was on a BMW F 800 GS. I think it was a 2009.

The same vein of adventure bike that the AT was.

However, it always felt the BMW was so much more advanced than the AT, as good as the AT was, it never had any where near the power the BMW had.

So where to next, I have never really liked the BMW's but maybe times are changing?

Has any one had direct comparison between the AT and the 650cc BMW or the 800cc BMW and the 750cc AT.
I get confused with the newer BMW F650 which is actually an 800cc, (why did they do that )
Please post your opinions, findings, call them what you may.

I know the smaller engine BMW is a single cyl, which many have said is a vibratory monster, and to opt for the twin.

Most, if not all my riding is on tarmac, with possible some hard compact gravel roads.

vette

It's interesting that after a year of using the AT you don't seem at all interested in buying one for yourself. I guess you have your reasons.
Certainly, they are over-priced in the UK, being something of a cult bike, especially after a bike magazine ran a test report a while back which recommended the AT as the best bike of a crop of so called adventure bikes.

Anyway, the F650GS name was retained by BMW when they marketed the F800GS so as not to lose the brand of that name; I got this opinion by speaking with Beemer sales staff at that time - it was also a means for BMW to meet their earlier commitment to bring to their showrooms at least a couple of new models of bike (or variations/developments of bikes such as the new water cooled 1200GS for next year), each and every year. Most recently they have gone into the large-engined scooter market for instance.

Regarding the single cyl, BMW have gone full circle and are now selling the G650GS, and the related Sertao, which are direct replacements for the earlier twin spark F650GS/Dakar range.
BMW publicity at the time said this was done because of the market demand for the single cyl engine which is still, to this day, one of the most economical engines available (mine does about 75 MPG - UK gallons that is, easily). It is also one of smoothest running singles and no way would I call that engine a vibratory monster - look to KTM 640s for that!!
Power output of the twin spark engine is nearly 50 HP which is close to the output of a 750cc AT I believe (of course, the AT is a much heavier beast).

There can be no doubt that the BMW market changed immensely, as outlined above, about 10 years ago; just ask those enthusiasts for the airheads and those who run loads of older models, or get hold of a copy of the BMW club magazine.

I hope this is of interest/use to you in your thoughts.

[Frank on AT]

You asked: "Has any one had direct comparison between the AT and the 650cc BMW"

Between 2000 and 2005 we lived in Bolivia - I had a wonderful Africa Twin (Frank on AT) and my wife had the F650GS.

The Africa Twin is an unbelievable robust bike, which I would always buy again.
The F650GS was a total desaster. The motor died around 14000 km in Brazil. I drove from Rio de Janeiro (where the BMW garage said because it was a german BMW I had no warranty) to the head office of BMW in Sao Paulo. They said, if I repaired the bike with BMW garage Rio (double price compared to the Suzuki garage offer) and the repair would fail, they would send the parts to Bolivia and repair it there. No warranty if I had chosen the Suzuki repair. Ok.
The repair did not last, a dying bike reached La Paz and although we claimed the written warranty in Brazil and Germany several times - we never got it....
The bike never drove again - my lesson: Never buy a BMW. Never trust even a written warranty. Repairs are double expensive than in rice-cooker-garages.

The Africa drove through all the worst you can imagine and had only minor failures - the worst was a contact in the sidestand, which connected "secretly" and made the engine ran unround. I drove at least 4 times to a garage until a smart guy in Iquique found it out.


Now:
After being without bike for five years I just had to decide what I wanted to buy. I knew what I wanted: A brandnew Africa Twin please!
But there is nothing on the market like that. So I just ordered a Yamaha XT1200Z Super Tenere.

Why?
Life-Rule number one: No BMW!
The Honda Crosstourer told me directly: "Don't you even think about driving me through anything but best roads!"
The Triumph - a friend told me "too much plastic" - but I liked her somewhat.

But in the end I wanted the Tenere. I could not find so many gimmicks on her, the test bike drove perfectly (even thru a german forest) and a BIG reason too was the price.
BMW and Triumph are crazy expensive compared to a Tenere.

I live again in the Latin Americas now and I need a robust bike with simple and proved technic. I do not need a showbike. I need a bike I can lose and get on again - and if the Tenere is not as robust as I hope at least I paid 30% less.

[bombdefuzer]

Originally Posted by Frank on AT

You asked: "Has any one had direct comparison between the AT and the 650cc BMW"

Between 2000 and 2005 we lived in Bolivia - I had a wonderful Africa Twin (Frank on AT) and my wife had the F650GS.

The Africa Twin is an unbelievable robust bike, which I would always buy again.
The F650GS was a total desaster. The motor died around 14000 km in Brazil. I drove from Rio de Janeiro (where the BMW garage said because it was a german BMW I had no warranty) to the head office of BMW in Sao Paulo. They said, if I repaired the bike with BMW garage Rio (double price compared to the Suzuki garage offer) and the repair would fail, they would send the parts to Bolivia and repair it there. No warranty if I had chosen the Suzuki repair. Ok.
The repair did not last, a dying bike reached La Paz and although we claimed the written warranty in Brazil and Germany several times - we never got it....
The bike never drove again - my lesson: Never buy a BMW. Never trust even a written warranty. Repairs are double expensive than in rice-cooker-garages.

The Africa drove through all the worst you can imagine and had only minor failures - the worst was a contact in the sidestand, which connected "secretly" and made the engine ran unround. I drove at least 4 times to a garage until a smart guy in Iquique found it out.


Now:
After being without bike for five years I just had to decide what I wanted to buy. I knew what I wanted: A brandnew Africa Twin please!
But there is nothing on the market like that. So I just ordered a Yamaha XT1200Z Super Tenere.

Why?
Life-Rule number one: No BMW!
The Honda Crosstourer told me directly: "Don't you even think about driving me through anything but best roads!"
The Triumph - a friend told me "too much plastic" - but I liked her somewhat.

But in the end I wanted the Tenere. I could not find so many gimmicks on her, the test bike drove perfectly (even thru a german forest) and a BIG reason too was the price.
BMW and Triumph are crazy expensive compared to a Tenere.

I live again in the Latin Americas now and I need a robust bike with simple and proved technic. I do not need a showbike. I need a bike I can lose and get on again - and if the Tenere is not as robust as I hope at least I paid 30% less.

I own a Africa Twin RD 7A and love it as well. Good choice on the 1200 Tenere !

BD