Go Back   Horizons Unlimited - The HUBB > Technical, Bike forums > Which Bike?
Which Bike? Comments and Questions on what is the best bike for YOU, for YOUR trip. Note that we believe that ANY bike will do, so please remember that it's all down to PERSONAL OPINION. Technical Questions for all brands go in their own forum.
Photo by Hendi Kaf, in Cambodia

I haven't been everywhere...
but it's on my list!


Photo by Hendi Kaf,
in Cambodia



Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
  #16  
Old 16 Jan 2008
AliBaba's Avatar
Registered Users
Veteran HUBBer
 
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Norway
Posts: 1,379
The weight issue is funny. As always people think that the traditional BMW-stuff is heavy. I compared the weight of swingarm, beveldrive/sprocket, driveshaft/chain on a R80GS and a F650GS Paris Dakar:

R80GS shaft 12,4kg
F650GS 9kg

That’s not to bad is it? …… Well if you need to carry a spare set of sprockets and chain the weight for the chain-bike will be 12.3 kg! Still 100 gram lighter but you need lubricants, a few chainlocks and maybe some tools.

Conclusion: Shaftdrive is not necessarily heavier then chain and sprockets!

Sidenote:
Small things like chain guard, chain followers and so on are not included in the weight stated above.

So:
Weight – The same
Cost – Shaft is less expensive in the long run
Maintenance – OldBmw has some good points here, personally I would prefer a few hours job every 100-150.000 km then the hassle with a chain.


Who cares?

Last edited by AliBaba; 16 Jan 2008 at 08:51. Reason: Added pic
Reply With Quote
  #17  
Old 16 Jan 2008
Registered Users
New on the HUBB
 
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Dorset,GB
Posts: 8
Since 1977,all of my bikes have been shaft-drive,CX500,6 Goldwings,5 BMWs.

I've done "serious" miles on all of 'em.For instance,my latest bike,bought new on August 1st '07, has done just under 11,000 miles!

I have never had a single problem with any shaft-drive.

Chains belong on bicycles!!
Reply With Quote
  #18  
Old 16 Jan 2008
Registered Users
Veteran HUBBer
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Estonia
Posts: 787
I have to agree with AliBaba, the weight difference isn't big, there is a small weight advantage for chain drive, but not as big as many people think it is.

The main con for shaft is the power loss, which is approximately 18%, chains drives have approximately 11% power loss from the crank. So this clearly dictates shaft drive isn't the best solution for very high performance road racing bikes. But for our consumer use adventure and adventure touring bikes, where 7% power difference wouldn't be noticed, I think we can argue about the cons and pros of each system.

Personally I prefer the shaft-drive. On BMW paralever, you can repair it on the road too, if you know how to do it. You need to carry a main bearing and/or a main seal just in case. They cost less than a good chain set, weight less and take less room carrying them with you.

Quote:
Originally Posted by AliBaba View Post
Who cares?
Very nice armored assault vehicle , imagine if it was a chain drive and you had to ride home that is 200kms away w/o cleaning and lubricating it, like I often do with my GS - how much chain wear it'll cause? Also if mostly riding on dirt and gravel roads? Even the "sealed" X- or O-ringed chains will give up faster in dirty conditions. Closed systems (both shaft and some enclosed chain drives some older bikes have) are the best there I think in terms of longevity and wear. If riding only on clean tarmac on Western-European and N-American clean main roads then high quality (D.I.D., Regina few other) chains last relatively long (up to 30Kkms, some even more if you aren't a very hard handed rider and clean/lubricate it after every 500km, or after every day when riding in rainy days), but it's a hassle in any case. Your rear wheel will be oily with dirt glued on and your girlfriend (maybe you too if you're too nasty on oiling the chain) will have oily boots, whether you have Scottoiler or you prefer to clean/oil it yourself and you have to keep an eye on it constantly anyway: overall condition, wear of the chain and sprockets, and constantly check&adjust chain slack... In comparision, any 20,000km or more manitenance intervalled (only oil change needed) shaft drive looks very convenient, since you even don't have to touch or look at it in between the maintenance intervals.

In the end of the day each system has it's advantage and disadvantages. Everyone has their own personal requirements, comfort-levels, technical skills and risk assessment in their minds to choose the one that suits the best, IMHO anyways.

Here's mine:



Mine's now at 73Kkm and not a single problem.

Last edited by Margus; 16 Jan 2008 at 14:07.
Reply With Quote
  #19  
Old 16 Jan 2008
Registered Users
Veteran HUBBer
 
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Saintfield N Ireland
Posts: 148
Honda did make a V twin with a shaft drive. The St110, and the Deauville as well as the CX500. But depending on what type of travelling you want to do depends on what bike you choose.

As you said most off roaders dont have shaft drive (apart from a few) for weight as most people say and to keep the bike slimmer and other reasons.

As for choosing a bike give us a possible price you would want to spend on (if you dont mind) the bike and we might be able to give you a few bikes we would think about. and what type of terrain you want to go on, road, bit of off roading, hardcore stuff

I plan to go to morroco and i just bought a Yamaha Xt660r for me i find it a great bike, cheap to run, comfy etc but it has a chain when my old bike a deauville had a shaft drive. But there are plenty of things out there to help stop you throwing money at them like scott oilers, degreasers to clean road crap from the chain etc etc
Reply With Quote
  #20  
Old 17 Jan 2008
Registered Users
HUBB regular
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Netherlands
Posts: 39
Seem to have spawned quite a discussion here on chains and shafts! After reading through all the posts the only thing one can conclude, as with all these sort of discussions, there are pro's and con's for both systems!

Biking wise I have no experience with long touring outside of europe, but i imagine that if you decide to drive over from up here to SA, it would be fun to get into less familiar type of biking. Probably not the hard core stuff, but some semi offroading, a bit of desert etc seem like a pretty cool experience! So that would probably mean a tenere/africa twin/kle etc enduro style bike. The near daily chain maintenance still scares me off a bit, but if that is what it takes and it can be done without too much problems, it seems like a minor price to pay for a wicked experience!

cheers for al the input

Paul
Reply With Quote
  #21  
Old 17 Jan 2008
Registered Users
Veteran HUBBer
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Posts: 1,598
[QUOTE=Margus;168730]

The main con for shaft is the power loss, which is approximately 18%, chains drives have approximately 11% power loss from the crank. So this clearly dictates shaft drive isn't the best solution for very high performance road racing bikes. But for our consumer use adventure and adventure touring bikes, where 7% power difference wouldn't be noticed, I think we can argue about the cons and pros of each system.
end quote

This is not a fixed thing Margus. On the diesel bike forum where bikes often run with a max of 9hp, transmission loss can be substantial. For instance the old Enfield gearbox when filled with grease as recommended consumes over 25% of the crankshaft power. Switching to 90 grade oil halves this, with a further decrease of power absorbtion when using 50 grade oil. The new (since 1995 or so) 5 speed gearbox on 50 grade oil will often allow a bike to go an extra 10mph, as it absorbs very little power.

Many modern bikes run the gears in the very thin synthetic engine oils which reduce drag to a minimum, wheras the bmw's use separate gear oil of 75/80 weight. Worse for BMW's is that the gearbox is directly coupled to the engine, so there is no primary reduction. This means the input shaft turns 2-3 times faster. to compound this problem, the output shaft is offset to drive the shaft. This forced BMW to use a gearbox that not only spins fast but final drive is via transverse cogs, all of which conspire to drain power. Old Gearboxes and most car gearboxes usually lock the input to the output on the same shaft, so in top gear power is not trasferred by energy wasting gears at all. This normally can easily be checked by looking to see if top gear is shown as a 1:1 ratio. Final drive ratio should always use the least amount of intermediaries for highest efficiency ( and probably component life).
Reply With Quote
  #22  
Old 17 Jan 2008
Registered Users
Veteran HUBBer
 
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: Estonia
Posts: 787
Quote:
Originally Posted by oldbmw View Post
This is not a fixed thing Margus. On the diesel bike forum where bikes often run with a max of 9hp, transmission loss can be substantial. For instance the old Enfield gearbox when filled with grease as recommended consumes over 25% of the crankshaft power. Switching to 90 grade oil halves this, with a further decrease of power absorbtion when using 50 grade oil. The new (since 1995 or so) 5 speed gearbox on 50 grade oil will often allow a bike to go an extra 10mph, as it absorbs very little power.

Many modern bikes run the gears in the very thin synthetic engine oils which reduce drag to a minimum, wheras the bmw's use separate gear oil of 75/80 weight. Worse for BMW's is that the gearbox is directly coupled to the engine, so there is no primary reduction. This means the input shaft turns 2-3 times faster. to compound this problem, the output shaft is offset to drive the shaft. This forced BMW to use a gearbox that not only spins fast but final drive is via transverse cogs, all of which conspire to drain power. Old Gearboxes and most car gearboxes usually lock the input to the output on the same shaft, so in top gear power is not trasferred by energy wasting gears at all. This normally can easily be checked by looking to see if top gear is shown as a 1:1 ratio. Final drive ratio should always use the least amount of intermediaries for highest efficiency ( and probably component life).
Hmmm...

I did dynoed my GS and guys who've dynoed most of the bikes and have extensive experiences on this field said the BMW-spec gearbox/paralever drive-train is within the power loss spec of most of other modern shaft-drived systems (or my over 60Kkms done GS performed well above factory performance specs to "cheat" the dyno machine results calculation), including japanese bikes with wet clutches and gearboxes floating in the crankcases in a very thin engine oil. I use spec oils only: usually 75W-90 GL5 both in gear- and bevel box.

The pro for BMW engine+gearbox system is all the shafts rotate parallel, which, at least in theory, should give the best mechanical efficiency and longevity - i.e. lot of unusually high mileage BMWs, Honda STs & Goldwings, some Guzzis. Engines where 90-degree turns are done have their own "uneffective" losses. So maybe that's why on dyno the BMW specs the same as other shaft-drived bikes that have all the friction going on in the thin engine oil, but with 90 degree turn at one point before it's transferred into shaft(?) I.e. bikes like Yamaha Diversion, Suzuki GS or VX, Honda XLV etc.

I agree the power loss ratio does vary, that's why I use the word "approximately" anyways. Depends on the temperatures of oils, mechanical details (i.e. Klingelnberg-Polloid spiral pattern in BMW paralevers), ratios, oil viscosity etc. But with modern shaft drived bikes the power loss is around 18% range running in common transmission oils in bevel boxes. I'm sure Enfields etc with different oils (even full of grease variant as you said) have different results and probably have more power loss than the modern siblings.

Last edited by Margus; 17 Jan 2008 at 09:18.
Reply With Quote
  #23  
Old 17 Jan 2008
AliBaba's Avatar
Registered Users
Veteran HUBBer
 
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Norway
Posts: 1,379
If you feel that the BMW is lazy because of all the powerloss in the driveline (which I personally don’t think is bad compared to an old beaten up chain) there are plenty of modifications that can be done to increase the power.

Somewhere in the North western corner of Tanzania my pannier more or less fell of when I landed after an unplanned jump. Wonder if chain and sprocket would have made it?



BTW. I also have a bike with chain :-)
Reply With Quote
  #24  
Old 17 Jan 2008
Registered Users
Veteran HUBBer
 
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Sax, Spain
Posts: 901
errr Yes!

Quote:
Originally Posted by AliBaba View Post

Somewhere in the North western corner of Tanzania my pannier more or less fell of when I landed after an unplanned jump. Wonder if chain and sprocket would have made it?
Wonder why they don't use SHAFT drive on Moto-cross bikes???

They jump a fair way!

Martyn
Reply With Quote
  #25  
Old 17 Jan 2008
AliBaba's Avatar
Registered Users
Veteran HUBBer
 
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Norway
Posts: 1,379
Quote:
Originally Posted by Martynbiker View Post
Wonder why they don't use SHAFT drive on Moto-cross bikes???

They jump a fair way!

Martyn
I guess they don’t have problems with panniers falling off?

MX is a bit different. They spend a few hours with service after they have ridden a few kilometers, but if that suits your travel-style it might be the right choice.
Reply With Quote
  #26  
Old 18 Jan 2008
Registered Users
Veteran HUBBer
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: UK
Posts: 4,343
Question How much do they weigh??

Quote:
Originally Posted by AliBaba View Post
The weight issue is funny. As always people think that the traditional BMW-stuff is heavy. I compared the weight of swingarm, beveldrive/sprocket, driveshaft/chain on a R80GS and a F650GS Paris Dakar:

R80GS shaft 12,4kg
F650GS 9kg

That’s not to bad is it? …… Well if you need to carry a spare set of sprockets and chain the weight for the chain-bike will be 12.3 kg! Still 100 gram lighter but you need lubricants, a few chainlocks and maybe some tools.

Conclusion: Shaftdrive is not necessarily heavier then chain and sprockets!
Hi Alibaba,
I just cannot imagine what it is about a couple of sprockets and a chain that adds up to 9 Kg.
Can't say I have ever weighed suchlike though.

I would "imagine", again I don't have weighing scales to hand, that the current crop of BMW shafties are heavier than the earlier models - they just look bigger and, therefore, heavier.
So, is it a useful comparison to take an old bike alongside a current production model (including the next generation of F650GS)?. I quite understand that you are riding one, so you have a personal interest!

I do like the way that BMW are prepared to manufacture bikes with all 3 common(ish) drive systems; shaft, chain and belt. In the next few years, we may see more of the chain drive models appearing, or belts for that matter.

Apart from this, I would just like to remind the original questioner that the chain drive bike can have it's gear ratios changed pretty easily - I don't hear or read of shaft drive owners fiddling with their gear ratios.
That's why the "racers" will always have a whole pile of sprockets and gearboxes for the various circuits - lets see how BMW are going to deal with this when they go racing!!
__________________
Dave
Reply With Quote
  #27  
Old 18 Jan 2008
AliBaba's Avatar
Registered Users
Veteran HUBBer
 
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Norway
Posts: 1,379
Quote:
Originally Posted by Walkabout View Post
Hi Alibaba,
I just cannot imagine what it is about a couple of sprockets and a chain that adds up to 9 Kg.
That's because the swingarm are included (for both shaft and chain). The swingarm are very different on shaft vs chain bikes.
Reply With Quote
  #28  
Old 18 Jan 2008
Registered Users
Veteran HUBBer
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: UK
Posts: 4,343
Ah!

Maybe difficult to separate out the functions for a shafty, but I may look around for a single-sided swing arm/chain drive and weigh it!
A Duc or a Triumph perhaps??!
__________________
Dave
Reply With Quote
  #29  
Old 18 Jan 2008
Registered Users
Veteran HUBBer
 
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Saintfield N Ireland
Posts: 148
Just thought of an even more different angle to look at this from, style/looks. I have never has someone say on look at that swing arm of a shalf bike, but you hear it all the time with sometime like a chain drive as they are more flexable and cheaper to produce using less materails to make them.

And there is a bike out there is there not with a seperate swing arm to shaft drive. The yamaha Dragster 800 and the suzuki marauder both have an outter frame for swing arma and a separate shaft drive unit. Looks weird but is more like a 1 off look.
Reply With Quote
  #30  
Old 18 Jan 2008
Registered Users
Veteran HUBBer
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: UK
Posts: 4,343
Quote:
Originally Posted by maxwell123455 View Post
Just thought of an even more different angle to look at this from, style/looks. I have never has someone say on look at that swing arm of a shalf bike, but you hear it all the time with sometime like a chain drive as they are more flexable and cheaper to produce using less materails to make them.

True, although I don't give a vast amount of credence to "styling" - it's important once the engineering is good.

But, there are lots of riders in the showrooms who judge by little else than the looks.
__________________
Dave
Reply With Quote
Reply


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 Registered Users and/or Members and 1 guests)
 

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
lubrication for drive chain jmrivet Yamaha Tech 7 16 Nov 2007 13:01
1988 r100 gs shaft drive radioactiveangel BMW Tech 4 5 Oct 2006 18:18
R1200GS Drive Shaft Area Noise and Leaking Oil jv3 BMW Tech 9 12 Jul 2005 22:32
Chain or shaft drive in Sahara? Skonte Which Bike? 1 21 Aug 2002 21:15
R1100gs Shaft Drive David A BMW Tech 5 12 Dec 2001 02:48

 
 

Announcements

Thinking about traveling? Not sure about the whole thing? Watch the HU Achievable Dream Video Trailers and then get ALL the information you need to get inspired and learn how to travel anywhere in the world!

Have YOU ever wondered who has ridden around the world? We did too - and now here's the list of Circumnavigators!
Check it out now
, and add your information if we didn't find you.

Next HU Eventscalendar

25 years of HU Events
Be sure to join us for this huge milestone!

ALL Dates subject to change.

2025 Confirmed Events:

Virginia: April 24-27
Queensland is back! May 2-5
Ecuador June 13-15
Germany Summer: May 29-June 1
CanWest: July 10-13
Switzerland: Date TBC
Ecuador: Date TBC
Romania: Date TBC
Austria: Sept. 11-14
California: September 18-21
France: September 19-21
Germany Autumn: Oct 30-Nov 2

Add yourself to the Updates List for each event!

Questions about an event? Ask here

See all event details

 
World's most listened to Adventure Motorbike Show!
Check the RAW segments; Grant, your HU host is on every month!
Episodes below to listen to while you, err, pretend to do something or other...

Adventurous Bikers – We've got all your Hygiene & Protection needs SORTED! Powdered Hair & Body Wash, Moisturising Cream Insect Repellent, and Moisturising Cream Sunscreen SPF50. ESSENTIAL | CONVENIENT | FUNCTIONAL.

2020 Edition of Chris Scott's Adventure Motorcycling Handbook.

2020 Edition of Chris Scott's Adventure Motorcycling Handbook.

"Ultimate global guide for red-blooded bikers planning overseas exploration. Covers choice & preparation of best bike, shipping overseas, baggage design, riding techniques, travel health, visas, documentation, safety and useful addresses." Recommended. (Grant)



Ripcord Rescue Travel Insurance.

Ripcord Rescue Travel Insurance™ combines into a single integrated program the best evacuation and rescue with the premier travel insurance coverages designed for adventurers.

Led by special operations veterans, Stanford Medicine affiliated physicians, paramedics and other travel experts, Ripcord is perfect for adventure seekers, climbers, skiers, sports enthusiasts, hunters, international travelers, humanitarian efforts, expeditions and more.

Ripcord travel protection is now available for ALL nationalities, and travel is covered on motorcycles of all sizes!


 

What others say about HU...

"This site is the BIBLE for international bike travelers." Greg, Australia

"Thank you! The web site, The travels, The insight, The inspiration, Everything, just thanks." Colin, UK

"My friend and I are planning a trip from Singapore to England... We found (the HU) site invaluable as an aid to planning and have based a lot of our purchases (bikes, riding gear, etc.) on what we have learned from this site." Phil, Australia

"I for one always had an adventurous spirit, but you and Susan lit the fire for my trip and I'll be forever grateful for what you two do to inspire others to just do it." Brent, USA

"Your website is a mecca of valuable information and the (video) series is informative, entertaining, and inspiring!" Jennifer, Canada

"Your worldwide organisation and events are the Go To places to for all serious touring and aspiring touring bikers." Trevor, South Africa

"This is the answer to all my questions." Haydn, Australia

"Keep going the excellent work you are doing for Horizons Unlimited - I love it!" Thomas, Germany

Lots more comments here!



Five books by Graham Field!

Diaries of a compulsive traveller
by Graham Field
Book, eBook, Audiobook

"A compelling, honest, inspiring and entertaining writing style with a built-in feel-good factor" Get them NOW from the authors' website and Amazon.com, Amazon.ca, Amazon.co.uk.



Back Road Map Books and Backroad GPS Maps for all of Canada - a must have!

New to Horizons Unlimited?

New to motorcycle travelling? New to the HU site? Confused? Too many options? It's really very simple - just 4 easy steps!

Horizons Unlimited was founded in 1997 by Grant and Susan Johnson following their journey around the world on a BMW R80G/S.

Susan and Grant Johnson Read more about Grant & Susan's story

Membership - help keep us going!

Horizons Unlimited is not a big multi-national company, just two people who love motorcycle travel and have grown what started as a hobby in 1997 into a full time job (usually 8-10 hours per day and 7 days a week) and a labour of love. To keep it going and a roof over our heads, we run events all over the world with the help of volunteers; we sell inspirational and informative DVDs; we have a few selected advertisers; and we make a small amount from memberships.

You don't have to be a Member to come to an HU meeting, access the website, or ask questions on the HUBB. What you get for your membership contribution is our sincere gratitude, good karma and knowing that you're helping to keep the motorcycle travel dream alive. Contributing Members and Gold Members do get additional features on the HUBB. Here's a list of all the Member benefits on the HUBB.




All times are GMT +1. The time now is 02:34.